CommentsPERSPECTIVE--Illegal sources of income are subject to federal and state income tax; so, why would I object to the City of Los Angeles collecting Transitory Occupancy Tax (TOT) revenue from illegal short-term rentals, such as Air BnB?
In the former case, taxation does not exempt scofflaws from prosecution. If anything, tax compliance requirements are useful tools to bring criminals to justice or enhance their sentences . If Al Capone were alive, he would agree.
The latter is different – it creates an impediment to enforcing zoning laws. A cash-strapped city like Los Angeles will not want to bite the hands that feed it. It is the equivalent of bribery. Pay to play, and the city will not pursue enforcement of residential zoning codes. The City Council and mayor will drag their feet, if not completely overlook, the protection of honest residents’ right to enjoy their neighborhoods without the adverse effects associated with revolving door occupancy.
In his annual budget letter to the mayor and City Council, City Controller Ron Galperin weighed in. He said the city must be “vigilant to consider the potential TOT revenue impacts to the general fund.”
As I read between the lines of his statement, that’s not really an endorsement of the policy. If anything, it is a carefully nuanced assessment. Ron is the controller and he is required to advise the city on any financial matter – good or bad.
But zoning violations should not be ignored just because the cash generated by the TOT partially mitigates the effects of the city’s reckless approach in managing its budget. Please note that Galperin also emphasized the importance of a prudent and well-balanced budget. Ignoring laws does not meet the definition of prudent.
It’s a good thing that a city-sanctioned, short-term rental scheme did not exist when Scarface Al was around. No telling how much more power he would have wielded in Chicago.
We now face an army of non violent mini-Als, no baseball bats or Chicago pianos, but armed with industry lawyers and plenty of money.
(Paul Hatfield is a CPA and serves as President of the Valley Village Homeowners Association. He blogs at Village to Village and contributes to CityWatch. The views presented are those of Mr. Hatfield and his alone and do not represent the opinions of Valley Village Homeowners Association or CityWatch. He can be reached at: [email protected].)
-cw
LA’s TOT an Unethical Budget Prop
