fbpx

Uninformed Juries Produce Incorrect Outcomes

PERSPECTIVE ON RITTENHOUSE - I was a troubled teen. I remember the day I was called to my high school’s administrative office to receive a call. He gave me advice I have never forgotten.

He told me that he had been notified that the police were going to arrest me and that I needed to tell the truth even if it was going to get me in trouble.

I was in my early thirties when I reflected upon this wisdom when performing part of his eulogy. It was horrible legal advice, but I know it saved my soul. 

The mistakes I made as a teenager have informed my whole life’s purpose. My doctoral dissertation, on forgiveness, would not have been written if I had not accounted for my own moral failings. 

Kyle Rittenhouse represents a character in the larger story of the divided American society. I follow these events and the attitudes and opinions surrounding them as an expert researcher focused on healing divided societies. There are many bifurcations, and the casualties that are not being discussed are healing and truth. His acquittal is a springboard, and the public is now at increased threat.

No criminal trial is motivated by healing or truth. Trials are about fact finding and fact exclusion. The Truth, for example, that after pleading not guilty earlier this year Kyle posed with Proud Boys while flashing a white power hand sign and T-shirt that said “Free as F—,” was not allowed in trial. Rittenhouse remains “Free as F—,” unpermitted facts notwithstanding.

This process focuses on justifying punishment for offenders who have been convicted beyond reasonable doubt, but uninformed juries cannot make informed decisions. 

This is not justice, and it does nothing for healing. The families of the victims, the communities, Kyle Rittenhouse, and so on… nothing about the process is intended to help them heal or find closure. Punitive justice serves a role, but there are other options. The verdict only affirms that the US remains committed to its long history of vigilantism, an ugly bloodlust embedded throughout the American mythology promoting white supremacy.

After I plead guilty, I had punishment. I had to pay fines and restitution, I was placed on probation, had my driver’s license suspended and I had to complete community service in lieu of incarceration. I’m not dismissing the presence of positive value in these features of punitive justice, but to acknowledge that it is incomplete. Rittenhouse will not experience any of those benefits, we can only hope that something else can stimulate healing and accountability.

If the US took restorative justice more seriously there would be considerable benefit to the communities and individuals impacted in these tragedies. These processes can create spaces for real dialog between victims and offenders, which is proven to increase accountability among offenders and empower victims. Making amends can help heal and even grow. 

If you do not believe growth is needed, consider the cultural questions being raised in the trial. Prosecuting attorney Binger observed, “I Think We Can All Agree We Shouldn’t Have 17-Year-Olds Running Around The Street With AR-15s Because This Is What Happens,” but clearly the alt-right and militia groups did not see it this way. 

The Southern Poverty Law Center, which tracks hate and extremism, has sounded alarms for Increases In Hate Crimes And Violence in recent years and observes the Lionization Of Rittenhouse Through “Not Factually Based” Propaganda.

Restorative processes could significantly help disrupt these cycles. Interrupting dishonest narratives would be a good start. I have personally observed no shortage of people who believe that the shootings were heroic acts of patriotism and whom claim they would like to have the chance to do the same thing. This reflects great ideological divides—not a melting pot—where difference is a justification for harm and not a source of strength. Each verdict—guilty or not—only makes the need of reconciliation greater.

 

(Wim Laven, Ph.D., syndicated by PeaceVoice, teaches courses in political science and conflict resolution. )

 

 

THE VIEW FROM HERE - America is a nation which runs on lies.  Worse yet, we are a nation where each group manufactures its own lies. 

Read more ...

NUCLEAR WASTE OF TIME - Tokyo Electric Power Company-TEPCO- has been attempting to decommission three nuclear meltdowns in reactors No. 1 No. 2, and No. 3 for 11 years now.

Read more ...

COMMENTARY -  Love thy enemy? I get a chance to do so on a regular basis, thanks to the email (or nasty-mail) I sometimes get in response to my column, e.g.:

Read more ...

WORKERS STRUGGLE - An analysis released this week shows that many of the employees of the nation’s largest grocery chain, Kroger, workers who manage and sell food, are themselves scrambling to get enough to eat, struggling with bills because of part-time and unpredictable schedules and contending, as front-line workers do, with the COVID threat

Read more ...

CORPORATE MALFEASANCE - In its ranking of business values, corporate America proudly provides a special place for elevated moral behavior. That place is the trash can.

Read more ...

THE DOCTOR IS IN - Unfortunately, human history has proven endemic both to regional (and now global) pandemics and to human trafficking (both slave/servant sales and sexual trafficking-- and child trafficking at that).

Read more ...

NUCLEAR POLITICS - Some countries claim that nuclear weapons exist to deter aggression—when in fact they are the most egregious aggressive threat to all of humanity. 

Read more ...

DEMOCRACY WATCH - One year ago, the foundation of our democracy was jeopardized in a full-blown coup attempt by seditionists egged on by former president Donald Trump. People died.

Read more ...

PROGRESSIVE POLITICS - Over the past several decades, the progressive Left has successfully fulfilled Antonio Gramsci’s famed admonition of a “long march through the institutions”.

Read more ...

THE CAPITOL - In retrospect, the attempted insurrection at the Capitol was about a great deal more than an angry expression of disappointment by the populist side of gun culture America.

Read more ...

MARC'S ANGLE - Americans are finally getting hip to the mass manipulation by the media.

Read more ...

RANDOM LENGTHS NEWS - Tens of thousands of Trump supporters attended the so called “Save America” rally on Jan. 6, 2021.

Read more ...

COMMENTARY - Since their inception, there have been many arguments both for and against charter schools. 

Read more ...

DEMOCRACY WATCH - As we approach the first anniversary of the attack on the United States congress, it is imperative to understand that the threat to democracy is not over.

Read more ...

INSURRECTION ANNIVERSARY - The defeat of Donald Trump in 2020 was supposed to put an end to America’s delusional national politics. 

Read more ...

WAR MACHINE - War spews hell in all directions.

Read more ...

THE VIEW FROM HERE - Bad things, horrible things, happen to people of all race, creed, and color in the United States.

Read more ...

COMMENTARY - "Without immediate action, we are at genuine risk of civil conflict and losing our precious democracy," the former president writes. "Americans must set aside differences and work together before it is too late." 

Read more ...

RantZ and RaveZ - As we arrive at 2022, I want to welcome back the readers of RantZ and RaveZ. 

Read more ...

COMMENTARY - Unless the Republicans and Democrats put the nation above their party and personal interests, our democracy will face the gravest danger in more than a hundred years.

Read more ...

THE DOCTOR IS IN - I'm as guilty as any of being garrulous, verbose, loquacious, etc. So, I'll try to keep things neat and sweet for our New Year: 

Read more ...