fbpx

Why LA’s Corrupt and Inefficient Court System Must be Reformed!

LA RECALLS-In my condo-rental-related lawsuit we ended up having five judges who heard the case.

This moving around of judges like pawns on a chessboard is utterly bizarre and inefficient. Each judge would not honor what the previous judge had instructed. It was truly maddening. 

And who does a self-represented litigant turn to when clear bias has raised its ugly head? No one. I turned to the Supervising Judge, Judge Cotton, but his response letters were offensive and devoid of facts – there truly was no one.   

When Judge Paul Bacigalupo sanctioned me over $2500 for serving a subpoena for email records to a defendant’s employer, no one, no lawyer, no appellate firm could make sense of it. But he got away with ignoring the Civil Code of Procedure without a blink of an eye. Was I going to pay $7500 to file a Writ to undo this very improper and very personal ruling? No. I did file a complaint against him to the CJP, but they ignored my complaint. 

In the past week or so I learned (from a CityWatch reader) that Bacigalupo was a Special Master for the CJP in 2018 at the time that I filed/mailed in my complaint. So, that explains them turning a blind eye. Is this what judicial oversight has become? No judge should have such power. In fact, Bacigalupo is working hard to make sure that we can no longer recall judges -- even forming a group to stop movements such as ours.   

According to a report in the Daily Post in Palo Alto, Bacigalupo said the group was formed in response to “increased attacks on the independence of the judiciary, the role of decision making and a misunderstanding about the role of a judge and the judicial system.” 

It’s precisely his “decision making” that we have a right to question as he and other judges continue to affect the lives of thousands each year. I am uncertain how this man thinks he has a right to even speak on the matter. He yelled at me with such rage within minutes of appearing in front of him for simply trying to tell him that the attorney calling in to the CMC hearing should not be appearing or heard because his clients were dismissed. This display of rage was not an isolated incident. 

As stated in my previous article, Bacigalupo also mocked my entire case and pleading. It must not have been that funny because I prevailed with a $300,000 settlement and was able to recoup on top of that his $2500 sanctions. In fact, I would not even go into mediation if the defendant would not agree to give me back the money since the ruling was so utterly bizarre. I would have continued to litigate if that money had not come back to me. 

This kind of ruling makes one feel like someone has stolen money from you when it blatantly contradicts the Code of Civil Procedure, and, based on the transcript, makes no sense whatsoever. It was very personal for this judge and it appeared that he had not read the response to the Protective Order or the actual subpoena for the email communications between defendants. 

Retired Judge Frank Johnson came back to the bench in 2018 around the time I was litigating. For some reason we were redirected to him from Dept. U on Demurrer day. A 13-page Tentative Ruling was waiting for me. He allowed out two of my defendants due to lack of privity on Negligence when California does not mandate one be in contract to sue for Negligence. This guy is probably in his seventies and there is case law going back at least 50 years backing this up. So he had to know this. He then sustained the same defendants’ Demurrer to Retaliation, claiming I didn’t prove they were an agent for my landlord even though the agency contract was an Exhibit in the complaint. I then had to pay an appellate firm to get involved. Why? How can a judge be so blatantly incompetent? And why should repercussions cost $20,000 or more? 

When you stand back and look at all of this it is hard not to wonder if there isn’t some form of conspiracy against self-represented litigants. Or are our judges just completely and utterly brain dead? 

Our movement is about taking three major steps: 

1.) The beginning of a recall movement that will span over years to come. 

2.) Seeking out opponents to each judge listed on LARecalls.com. Other judges will be added in the future. 

3.) Judicial Reform. 

Oversight of these judges is abysmal and that’s unacceptable. They are not gods and we need to make sure they start waking up to that fact. They need to fear losing their jobs -- just like every other Californian. 

While we appreciate the California State Auditor looking into the CJP, it was not enough. They have given the CJP way too much time to implement minor changes. We need committees formed that will come up with resolutions and panels to review the thousands of complaints that come in each year against biased and unhinged judges. And why not have a committee or panel in each court for self-represented litigants or any litigant, for that matter, to contact once a blatantly biased ruling comes in and/or evidence of ex parte communications is exposed. 

There is money for all of this -- it’s just that it’s being used to supplement judges’ salaries. Why did they take away court reporters in civil cases? Waiting months and years for a resolution after a bad ruling, costs litigants and the voters money. We already know that most self-represented litigants can’t afford to hire an appellate firm so the absurd rulings will not be overturned. This is not justice. Do panel members need to consist of lawyers and retired judges or those with a mere understanding of CCP and the California Rules of Court? I don’t know. I mean, it’s not rocket science, but I don’t know the answer. I do know that we need a panel for the people and not for the judges -- and we need to get this conversation going NOW. With each passing day that these judges sit on the bench they are stripping victims of their right to be heard and in many cases, their freedom.  

You can do your own due diligence by going to BallotPedia and check on your own judge to see when their term is up. Seek out lawyers in your communities to oppose them. With no one opposing them they will automatically be reelected.  

It does not go unnoticed that judges like Bacigalupo are associated with the CJA, the CJP and the State bar. This is the way certain judges can build a Teflon wall around them so that no one can touch them. While Bacigalupo does not come up for reelection until 2021, we can get him off the bench much sooner with your help.  

If you are passionate and truly want to help our cause, please sign up to volunteer and let us know in what capacity you believe you can help. Let us know if you are a member of a church, a community or sit on a school board. Do you know others who agree that we need great reform in our court system? Are you yourself able to circulate petitions? Involve your communities, your family and friends. This is a movement that is not going away. Are you registered to vote? If not, and you live in LA County, go to your local post office and register. Let us know how you can help at LArecalls.com or email us at: [email protected]  

If you don’t have time but you want to support our much needed and long overdue movement, please donate as much as you can here.   

To all lawyers reading this: We are currently seeking an opponent to run against Judge Alison Mackenzie (photo left) who must appear on the ballot in 2020. Please reach out to us at [email protected] if you are up to the task.

 

(Shelly Hart prevailed in one of the largest settlements in CA and quite possibly the nation as a self-represented litigant. She is uniquely qualified to write on this topic and is one of the handful of individuals who is heading up LARecalls, the recall of several LA Superior Court judges. You can contact her at [email protected]) Edited for CityWatch by Linda Abrams.

 

 

GUN CONTROL - As California tries to crack down on crime, it secured a sizable victory for its strict gun control laws on Tuesday. 

Read more ...

CALIFORNIA POLITICS - During the most recent legislative session in California, at least three senators on powerful environmental and finance committees derived significant income from fossil fuel companies, according to financial disclosures obtained by Capital & Main.

Read more ...

Thank you, America, for always keeping California in your thoughts.

Read more ...

COMMENTARY - With this month’s U.N. climate conference failing to achieve key agreements that will limit global heating to the crucial 1.5° C goal, it’s vital that California step up our climate leadership. 

Read more ...

EDUCATION POLITICS  - Then-Gov. Jerry Brown and the Legislature overhauled California’s public school financing in 2013 with the stated goal of closing the “achievement gap” separating poor and English-learner students from more privileged children.

Read more ...

ENVIRONMENT WATCH - Deep in the oil fields of western Kern County, a little northwest of the century-old town of McKittrick, hundreds of thousands of gallons of crude oil and wastewater filled with toxic chemicals have been seeping out of the ground for two years, in an area where companies operate hundreds of wells.

Read more ...

CALIFORNIA WATCH - When it comes to California departures, I have no problem with the number of Californians moving out.

Read more ...

JOB FORCE - Officially, California has 1.4 million unemployed residents, but a new study that takes into account people who can’t find jobs that pay above poverty level says the number of “functionally unemployed” is three times higher at 4.8 million.

Read more ...

CALIF JOB FORECAST - Each month, federal and state officials release employment data for the preceding month, basically telling us how many Californians are employed and how many aren’t.

Read more ...

POLITICS - “I just took [my son] to our local Walgreens to buy him a toy. While there, a man shoved past me so firmly that he sent me into the shelving. Then he proceeded to fill a brown paper bag with Halloween candy and waltzed out of the store. This is one of five Walgreens stores in SF that will be closing in the next two months, in part because of rampant theft. And our city leaders all keep insisting crime is down.”

Read more ...

HOUSING CRISIS - The California Apartment Association, the landlord lobbying group, is one of the most powerful organizations in California.

Read more ...

CLIMATE WATCH - Nations convening at the United Nations climate conference pledged today to end the sale of new gasoline-powered cars in major markets by 2035 and globally by 2040, mirroring California’s plans. 

Read more ...

REDISTRICTING - A congressional map that splits Long Beach into two.

Read more ...

STATE OF THE UNIONS - Shirley Reyes tucked herself next to her 17-year-old son on the couch, peppering him with questions about unions as he googled the cost and benefits of collective bargaining on his phone.

Read more ...

CLIMATE CHANGE - Officials warn that next year’s cuts in water supply could go even deeper as severe drought grips nearly 90% of California.

Read more ...