Last updateMon, 27 Jul 2015 7pm

LOS ANGELES Wednesday, July 29th 2015 12:59


Thoroughly Modern Bob – Coming to a Legislature Near You!

Paul Hatfield
PERSPECTIVE-Thoroughly Modern Millie was a Tony Award winner. State Senator Bob Hertzberg is rolling out his own sequel. The only problem is the production cost. Actually, the real problem is we will be the ones bankrolling it if Bob gets the green light. It is the most expensive tax scam concocted, more than California HSR. I’m talking…

Elite Girls School Has Brentwood Up in Arms … Over Traffic

John Schwada
INSIDE LA-Hairdresser Mikell Powell is walking her two dogs in Brentwood along Sunset Boulevard just across the street from the Archer School for Girls (photo left). “I’m opposed to anything that would make driving on Sunset here anymore hellish than it already is,” Powell says as her dogs tug on their leashes. No question: there’s a 1.2 mile…

Homeless LA: Safe Havens, Not Sidewalks

Mike Bonin
WHO WE ARE-In recent years, Los Angeles has seen more progress in combating homelessness than it ever has – yet the problem is still getting worse. Since 2011, the region has housed more than 23,000 people – a record number even by national standards. Yet homelessness is on the rise. Encampments are proliferating in our neighborhoods throughout…

Can LA Afford Another Olympics?

Jack Humphreville
LA WATCHDOG-Boston bailed on hosting the 2024 Olympics when Mayor Martin Walsh refused to sign a host city contract with the United States Olympic Committee (“USOC”) that would have put Beantown (and possibly the Commonwealth of Massachusetts) on the hook for any cost overruns associated with this 17 day extravaganza. But Walsh’s refusal to…

The Petty Hypocrisy of Mandatory Ethics Training

Bob Gelfand
GELFAND’S WORLD-As a member of a neighborhood council board, I am required by state law to do 2 hours of ethics training every 2 years. Elected officials such as members of the City Council are also required to take this training. The curious thing about our California ethics rules is that they prohibit the small stuff while looking the other way…

Los Angeles: Brown lives Matter!

Fred Mariscal
LATINO PERSPECTIVE-According to the Los Angeles Times, over the last five years in LA County, coroner's data show that Latinos, who make up about half of the county's population, also represent about half the people killed by police. Of the 23 people fatally shot by law enforcement in the county this year, 14 were Latino. The Times raises an…

Grading the LA Times: Mike Feuer’s B+ Leaves Something Out

Noel Weiss
OTHER VOICES-Reading the LA Times’ Report Card grade of B+ for City Attorney Mike Feuer, it was good to see at least a 'hat-tip' to the issue of whether the City Attorney really is the “attorney for the people.” But their conclusion seems to be that he is not, and I believe that is wrong. Exactly who does the City Attorney represent? Certainly, he…

Beverly Hills Pounds Final Nail in Bike Lanes Coffin

Mark Elliot
GETTING THERE FROM HERE-If you expected that Beverly Hills might install bicycle lanes on our segment of Santa Monica Boulevard when reconstructing it next year, you will be sorely disappointed to know that City Council just pounded the final nail into the bike lanes coffin. City Council split on the Blue Ribbon Committee recommendation to expand…

Helter Skelter, Murder and the Looming Race War

Tony Castro
TONY CASTRO’S LA-In one of our last conversations before his death earlier this year, author and prosecutor Vincent Bugliosi lamented that while he had successfully imprisoned Charles Manson, he feared he had only made a dent in the threat of an apocalyptic race war that the mass murderer had hoped to ignite. “Madness and mad men,” said Bugliosi,…


Reynolds Rap Video: Joey has hope for the pope in Philly.

You’re gonna cry! Kids sing to teacher with cancer

Scarrrry! The Flying Gun

Kid Stuff! Full of chuckles

LADWP Rates Overview







Busting City Hall’s Big Budget Myth: Declining Revenues

LA WATCHDOG - Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and the City Council have gone to great lengths to blame the City’s financial woes on the substantial decline in the General Fund’s tax and fee revenues. This has resulted in substantial operating deficits that have been overcome year after year by the “bold and creative leadership” of the Mayor and the City Council.

These “solutions” have resulted in a substantially lower level of service to Angelenos as 5,000 civilian employees have been removed from the General Fund payroll, resulting in a level of civilian employees not seen since the Mayor Bradley era (1973 to 1993).

The “solutions” have also been very costly.

Under the Early Retirement Incentive Program (the E-RIP), 2,400 senior employees were offered $355 million of increased retirement benefits. This amounts to $150,000 for each early retiree and does not include cash payments averaging $15,000 for unused vacation and sick days.  

The E-RIP will require the General Fund to fork over $600 million over the next 15 years, about 40% to 45% of which will be financed by City employees through a voluntary 1% contribution of their wages.

Another 1,600 employees, along with their unfunded pension liabilities of almost $200 million, were dumped on our Department of Water and Power, while additional surplus workers were transferred to the other two proprietary departments, the Port of Los Angeles and Los Angeles World Airports, and to other special revenue departments.

Overall, there have been less than 500 layoffs.

However, there is a minor problem with the tale of declining revenues that City Hall is spinning: the facts.

This year’s General Fund revenues are budgeted to be almost $850 million higher than 2005, the year Antonio Villaraigosa was elected mayor.  This 23% increase has resulted in record revenues of almost $4.5 billion, exceeding the previous high in 2009 by almost $125 million.

Furthermore, there has been only one year when revenues declined, in 2009 when they dipped by $132 million, or 3%.

Rather, the City’s financial crisis has been caused by the massive increase in salaries, benefits, and pension contributions of at least $1.3 billion since 2005, outstripping the increase in revenues by over $450 million.

During this period, the average salary of a civilian worker increased by almost 24% to over $72,000 a year and is scheduled to go up another 11.5% by July 1, 2014.  In addition, the total cost of benefits rose 50% and the City’s pension contributions exploded by 150%.

A major contributor to this increase in personnel expense was the execution of the 2007 labor agreement where the City, led down the garden path by the politically ambitious members of the closed door Executive Employee Relations Committee, agreed to increase the salaries of civilian workers by an mind boggling 25% over a five year period.  

(Note: The Executive Employee Relations Committee in 2007 consisted not only of the Mayor, but wannabe mayors Eric Garcetti and Wendy Greuel and wannabe Controller Dennis Zine, all of whom are running for cover these days, blaming the recession and the unpredictability of revenues. Gene Maddaus of LA Weekly offers an interesting insight into the disastrous 2007 contract in his recent article, The Villaraigosa Hangover.)

The escalation in personnel costs is also the underlying reason that the City is projecting a budget deficit of $216 million next year as the $300 million bump in personnel costs dwarfs the $70 million increase in revenues.

After the November elections, the City will be putting the full court press on us, the voters of Los Angeles, to approve $150 million of “revenue enhancements” (the politically correct term for new “taxes”), consisting of a doubling of the Documentary Transfer Fee (already the highest in the County) and a 50% increase in the Parking Occupancy Tax.

But what do we get in return, other than a lot of hot air?

The Mayor’s attempt at pension reform is nothing but a public relations stunt that does not address the pension liabilities associated with current City employees.  The City’s projected 2017 pension contribution of almost $1.3 billion, up over 50% from the current level, is lowered by only $15 million, or a little more than 1%.

In the past, the City has touted its “structural” solutions.  

But for the most part, they have been “kick the can down the road” solutions, relying on one time revenue fixes and the deferral of expenses to “balance” the General Fund.  The City has also deferred the repair and maintenance of our streets, sidewalks, parks, and the rest of our infrastructure and decimated various departments and their programs.  

City Hall does not have a revenue problem.  

Rather, it has a credibility issue as Angelenos do not trust the Mayor, the City Council, the Controller, the City Attorney, and their cronies, including the leadership of the public sector labor unions, to handle their money in a prudent and responsible manner.

If the City wants voters to approve $150 million in new taxes (excuse me, “revenue enhancements”), the City must endorse structural reform of its financial affairs by placing on the ballot a measure that requires the City to “Live Within Its Means.”

This common sense amendment would require the City to develop and adhere to a Five Year Financial Plan, approve two year balanced budgets based on Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, and, over the next ten years, provide adequate funding for the elimination of the City’s unfunded $10 billion pension liability and the repair and maintenance of our streets, parks, sidewalks, and the rest of our crumbling infrastructure.

While the myth of declining revenues is just another fairy tale emanating from the spinmeisters who occupy City Hall, one fact remains: Angelenos will not approve any new taxes or fees unless there is meaning financial reform.

It is very simple: No reform.  No revenues.

(Jack Humphreville writes LA Watchdog for CityWatch He is the President of the DWP Advocacy Committee and the Ratepayer Advocate for the Greater Wilshire Neighborhood Council. Humphreville is the publisher of the Recycler -- He can be reached at: –cw

Vol 10 Issue 78
Pub: Sept 28, 2012